Redux is Overhyped

by shakibaon 10/31/2016, 8:27 PMwith 4 comments

by acemarkeon 10/31/2016, 9:34 PM

The author submitted this on Reddit a couple days ago to /r/javascript, then deleted the submission after a very negative reception. That discussion is at https://www.reddit.com/r/javascript/comments/5a4irf/redux_is... . Looks like this is a second try in a different venue, I guess.

There's actually a bit of truth to the article title (Dan Abramov himself has said as much many times), but the article itself is rather short and kind of incoherent.

by mixedCaseon 10/31/2016, 9:47 PM

Call it overhyped or whatever, it is a nice pattern ('ve never used Redux but still use the pattern) for separating the data from the actual presentation logic. This provides great convenience when debugging and is a great solution to the mobile lifecycle problem.

If your article was just about saying "it isn't a silver bullet", I don't think anyone with any experience actually working with it would think it's a great idea for simple applications.

by gandolfinmyheadon 10/31/2016, 8:51 PM

warning: instance of the (<start> {{architecure}} is Overhyped, <mutter mutter...> always use the best tool for the job <end>) medium article class